Langsung ke konten utama

Novel Critical Review - Summer in The City by Robyn Sisman



Book Title        : Summer in The City
Author              : Robyn Sisman
Publisher          : Penguin Group
Date Published: 2005                                      
Number of pages: 309
Genre               : Romance                              

Summer in the City by Robyn Sisman tells the story of two complete strangers who live separated in London and New York having fate to be connected to each other by advertising Jobs. They have a long-distance relationship only by phone before they actually met and get attracted to each other. Suze Wilding who lived in London had to travel to New York for job business exchange her apartment with Lloyd Rockwell who also had to fly to New York. Their connection began when Suze knew that Lloyd had his job fired and decided to help him to get it back. Lloyd found it wonderful and both of them wondering if they just be perfect for one another at the end of the day.
            The novel has romance as its genre and makes Suze Wilding and Lloyd Rockwell as the main characters of this novel. Suze Wilding mentioned herself as a feminist who never wanted to have a serious relationship with a man. Otherwise Lloyd Rockwell is a man who ready to take big responsibility to live together with Betsy, who became his fiancée in the middle of the story. Suze was described as an independent and clever woman who was adored by her fellows’ partner at works, as well as Lloyd but he got bad luck when someone was trying to trap him until he got fired. Their presence in the novel as the main characters developed well from a man who loves his fiancée so much but realized married was not his first choice and a woman who stated love was not everything but still feeling hurt and fell into the wrong man.
Well, even though the main characters success dominated the whole plot, my pick to be the character wasn’t fall into one of them, but Betsy, the supportive character. I don’t know if I have second lead syndrome or no but I get emotional every time I read Betsy part who being hurt by Lloyd. She was a beautiful woman who really loves her man and being loyal to him and only wanted to be treated and loved well by her man. She deserved better than Lloyd had ever done to her. She accompanied Lloyd to London because she wanted to be always on Lloyd side, but Lloyd didn’t appreciate it by telling her that he didn’t insist her, she voluntarily to do so. She had been with Lloyd for years but Lloyd let her down for a small mistake that she did. I wish I have such loyalty to my future partner and patience. I think her effort to be a loyal and patience woman should be appreciate more.
The interesting part I found along the story was when Lloyd communicating with Suze by Telephone. The topic wasn’t really important but they had the chemistry to point they can share what they had been through on their day. The topic somehow ridiculous, once Lloyd told Suze that he unintentionally made her cat died on the way to vet. Suze also didn’t mind to share that she got dumped by Nick and had cried for a day because of that. Their chemistry was amazing though it happened indirectly, in two separate places.
I hate it when it near by the ending of the novel where Betsy and Lloyd broke up. I had mention that Betsy had my side, that’s why I get emotional by the reason Lloyd decided to broke up with her. I believe Suze had contribution to their broke up because Lloyd always mention her name in unconsciously in front of Betsy. Once, Betsy mother visited them in London and asked to be accompanied by Lloyd sightseeing around, but he refused due to his important job. But then, when he met Suze, he said that he relieved that he didn’t have to accompany Betsy Mother. I could understand why he was very rude towards his girlfriend’s mother who would become his mother in law. I was happy that Betsy didn’t have to continue her relationship with a coward like him.
            Although I didn’t like Suze and Lloyd, I believe the story will be better if the author give the resolution to their relationship in the of the novel.
However, the story would be much better if the author put more exposure on Nathan’s existence in the story. If I am the author I would make clear the status between him and Catherine and give resolution in the end of the story even though he was only the supportive character throughout the novel. Their love line remains hanging without being solved and makes Catherine looks like a bad character. Catherin deserves better ending on romance for what she had been through towards the member of the club and after her miserably days.
The friendship of KC, Peri, Lucie, Darwin, Catherine, Anita, and Dakota looks very sincere regardless their ages. The age different between five of them with Dakota made them treat her way better. I never found such friendship happened in real live. The way they support and care to each other was mesmerizing, it triggered me to remember my old fine days I spent with my friends. The differences I had with them are the intensity of meeting and communicating. Their last friendship moved me so much.
From the novel I can learn that friend can be more than friend. Calling our friend as our family is possible as long as our friendship is sincere. It is reflected on Friday knitting club on Walker and Daughter on how they felt the same blue when they were left by Georgia, how they try to resolve each other problem, how they gathered both for congratulate happiness or sadness. Even though in some reason not all of the problem they had can be shared, they tried their best to maintain their friendship at the end of the day.

Komentar

Postingan populer dari blog ini

Textbook Review - In Focus A vocabulary, reading and critical thinking skills course by Charles Browne, Brent Culligan, Joseph Phillips

Book Title                    : In Focus A vocabulary, reading and critical thinking skills course Author                          : Charles Browne, Brent Culligan, Joseph Phillips Publisher                      : Cambridge University Press Date Published             : 2014                Number of Page           : 106 Genre                          : Workbook      A. Explain the chapters one by one Chapter 1 The first topic of this book is gender equalit y which mainly discussed the equality of the sexes in society. This topic provides two texts each with different types of questions and activities. The first text titled the Iron Lady which tells the story of Margaret Thacher who became the first leader in United Kingdom political party that was traditionally run by white males. The second text titled what if the women ruled the world which explains the reasons why women are often superior to men. The pictures given to both texts illustrate the contents of the

Suffers, Miracles, and Extravagant Love, A Novel Review of Four Letters of Love by Niall Williams

Suffers, Miracles, and Extravag ant Love Title                 : Four Letters of Love Author             : Niall Williams Edition            : 1998 (Second Edition) Place               : London Publisher         : PICADOR ISBN               : 0-330-35269 Pages               : 342 Four Letters of Love written by Irish author Nial Williams is a magnificent novel about love, live, and destiny . It is a must read novel for everyone who likes slice of life stories that is full of impressively beautiful romance and bittersweet of love. It is written in a unique parallel way of stories from chapter to chapter. The 342 pages bring us the unforgettable journey of tragedies and miracle of life that makes us wonders how can love be this extravaging. Basically, four letters of love told us about two separated human being who lived in different side of the country met in unexpected way. Nicholas Coughlan who lived in Dublin discovered his feelings of love towards Isabel

Viola vs Violin

VIOLA VS VIOLIN Being a fan of classical music gives me new the knowledge of some instruments. Even though I am not a musician, I am interested in classical instruments and orchestra. One of the instruments that attract me the most is Violin. Before I go deeper to know more about violin, I thought violin is the English translation of Biola in Indonesia and had no clues about viola, but after I watched some YouTube videos and did some web-surfing, I realized that viola and violin are two different instruments. Here are some differences and similarities between those look alike instruments. If I catch a glimpse of both instruments, they look like twin. I might call viola as violin and other way around. But if we observe the details, their differences on physical appearances are obvious. The wooden materials and accessories such as case, bow, strings, tuner, chin and shoulder rest might deceive us, but if we look further on their size, measurements and clef I can tell they ar